Dr. Sarah's UCO 1200 First Year Seminar - Fall 2009
Breakthroughs and Controversies in Science and Mathematics

  • Office Hours this week
  • ASULearn (messages, forum, grades, and select readings)
  • Syllabus and Grading Policies
  • Mathematics and Science Activities at Appalachian
  • Class highlights If you miss a class, then check here and make up the work before the next class.
  • Jump down to tomorrow's homework which is located above the red lines
    Date     WORK DUE at the beginning of class unless otherwise noted! Other Work TBA
    14 Dec - Mon
  • Final Project Presentations from 9-11:30.
  • __________ ________________________________________________________________________
    __________ ________________________________________________________________________
    7 December - Mon
  • Prepare to orally present your final project abstract (like a commercial or advertisement) in 1-2 minutes.
  • Pizza Hut Buffet. The buffet is open from 5:30-7:30 and I will pay for your buffet.
  • 2 December - Wed
  • Project 5: University Sponsored Activities
  • 30 November - Mon
  • Work on project 5 and the final project and write down any questions you have.
  • Prepare to share with the class the recent news article that interests you about a breakthrough or controversy in science or mathematics from the assignment on Monday October 26 (we already analyzed the article for formal writing and rewrote some of it informally, but now you will be asked to share what you found in the article)
  • 23 November - Mon
  • TAKING SIDES reading on reflection on Are Genetically Modified Foods Safe to Eat? Message the following to me on ASULearn or turn in the answers at the beginning of class (also be prepared to discuss these). Your response needs to be formal and typed.
    1) Write down two items that you found interesting, that surprised you, or that you disagreed with.
    2) Design an experiment to test this issue.
  • 19 November - Thur
  • MOMIX at Farthing at 8pm. The doors open at 7:30pm.
  • 18 November - Wed
  • Meet in the library at 3:30 in room 028 for preliminary research related to unsolved problems or questions related to topics you are interested in and may work on for the final project.
  • Before class, read the final project description and choose a topic.
  • 16 November - Mon
  • Project 4: On the Shoulders of Giants - Two-Page Timeline, Presentation and Annotated References is due.
  • 11 November - Wed
  • Meet in CAP 252 at 3:30 for class with Dr. Donovan Leonard.
  • Choose a video related to science or mathematics from TED: Ideas worth spreading. Watch the video and reflect:
    1) What is an unsolved problem that relates to this topic?
    2) What are the contributions of the speaker?
    3) Write down two items that you found interesting, that surprised you, or that you disagreed with.
  • 9 Nov - Mon
  • TAKING SIDES reading on reflection on Should Potential Risks Slow the Development of Nanotechnology? Message the following to me on ASULearn or turn in the answers at the beginning of class (also be prepared to discuss these). Your response needs to be formal and typed.
    1) Write down two items that you found interesting, that surprised you, or that you disagreed with.
    2) Do you believe that the development of nanotechnology should be slowed? Why or why not - ie which arguements are most compelling to you?
  • 4 November - Wed
  • Meet in the library at 3:30 in Room 026 for research related to project 4.
  • Before class, read the project 4 description again, and choose a topic.
  • 2 Nov - Mon
  • TAKING SIDES reading on reflection on Can Machines be Concious? Message the following to me on ASULearn or turn in the answers at the beginning of class (also be prepared to discuss these). Your response needs to be formal and typed.
    1) Write down two items that you found interesting, that surprised you, or that you disagreed with.
    2) Design an experiment to test this issue (you may design your experiment for the far future if you desire).
  • 28 October - Wed
  • Respond to at least 2 different people's forum posts on ASULearn.
  • Read the Placebo effect. Briefly summarize the experiments that are mentioned in the article (for example: one set of experiments were open trials in which drugs and placebos were given by pill or injection versus hidden trials in which they were randomly administered by a hidden computer through an IV line)
  • 27 October - Tues
  • Class Chooses Activity. Meet in Walker 105 at 6:30pm. Bring games/sports/DVD movies with you and we'll decide what to do as we eat.
  • 26 October - Mon
  • Research the web to find a recent news article that interests you about a breakthrough or controversy in science or mathematics and prepare to share what you found. For example, you might find an article from the Science Times or Science News from Slashdot. Print the article or print at least one paragraph from the article.
  • 21 Oct - Wed
  • Think about what you would like to do for our class activity on Tuesday October 27. Some previous suggestions were food and a movie night or game night. Message me or write down (to turn in) your top 3 suggestions, which might include specific food, games, movies, or other activities.
  • Read through Project 4: On the Shoulders of Giants - Two-Page Timeline, Presentation and Annotated References which is due on November 16.
  • 19 October - Mon
  • Meet in 209b Walker for class.
  • On the ASULearn forum, add a new discussion topic titled by your name. Utilize formal language:
    1) Where do you consider your home? Tell us about your home.
    2) Attach a picture that you like (within the professional bounds of the classroom environment), and summarize the picture.
  • TAKING SIDES reading and reflection on Will the Search for Extraterrestrial Life Ever Succeed? p. 245-262. Message the following to me on ASULearn or turn in the answers at the beginning of class (also be prepared to discuss these). Your response needs to be formal and typed.
    1) State two facts presented by each side.
    2) State two opinions presented by each side.
    3) Write down two items that you found interesting, that surprised you, or that you disagreed with.
  • 14 October - Wed
  • Project 3: Interview and Research Reflection is due.
  • A laptop with the ability to obtain a wireless connection in class will be useful.
  • 12 October - Mon
  • Meet in 209b for class.
  • If you have obtained a list of scholarly work/research from the faculty member who you are interviewing in person, say from the relevant portion of the cv or resume, then bring a paper copy with you to class.
  • TAKING SIDES reading and reflection on the introduction p. xvii-xxix. Message the following to me on ASULearn or turn in the answers at the beginning of class (also be prepared to discuss these).
    Write down three items that you found interesting, that surprised you, that you disagreed with, and/or relates to your own life. Label your responses 1 though 3.
  • 7 October - Wed
  • By this date, come into office hours for a short conference. There is no need to make an appointment - just come anytime during my posted office hours.
  • Find a faculty member on campus who conducts scholarly work/research related to your future intended field, to science, or to mathematics, and who is willing to be interviewed in person (you may work in a group of 2 people or you may work alone).
  • 5 October - Mon
  • Skim the DNA research article Mystery Solved: The Identification of the Two Missing Romanov Children Using DNA Analysis. There may be forensic chemistry, biology and/or probability content that is beyond the scope of our backgrounds. So "skim" means that we should process what is possible with our current background knowledge and let the rest "roll-off".
  • Prepare to discuss the article and to share one controversy related to DNA typing (this may be unrelated to this article).
  • Sep 30 - Wed
  • Project 2: Response Paper on the summer reading book and convocation speech or the TAKING SIDES reading and librarian demonstration on related research. This project will be graded using the following rubric.
  • Sep 28 - Mon
  • TAKING SIDES reading and reflection on Will Hydrogen Replace Fossil Fuels for Cars? p. 100-122. Message the following to me on ASULearn or turn in your answers at the beginning of class (also be prepared to discuss these, so you may want to make a copy of whatever you turn in). This can be written as bullet points instead of paragraph form, but your response needs to be formal and typed.
    1) State two facts presented by each side.
    2) State two opinions presented by each side.
    3) How credible is each author (empirical in presenting the thesis, good credentials, biased in any way)?
    4) Are there any logical errors (like faulty cause/effect relationships, distortion of information, faulty analogy, oversimplification, stereotyping, faulty generalization)? If so, explain where and how.
  • Sep 23 - Wed
  • Begin working on Project 2. Utilize the writing center.
  • Group Interaction Course from 3:30-6:45. Required unless you have documented evidence of a conflict that you are unable to get out of, like a class, or work where your supervisor will not let you have time off.
  • Sep 21 - Mon
  • Project 1: Defining Moments Research and Annotated References
  • Sep 16 - Wed
  • Complete the preliminary research related to Defining Moments and bring two copies with you to the library atrium at 3:30 for class.
  • Sep 14 - Mon
  • TAKING SIDES reading and reflection on Is It Ethically Permissible to Clone Human Cells? p. 353-375. Message the following to me on ASULearn or turn in your answers at the beginning of class (also be prepared to discuss these, so you may want to make a copy of whatever you turn in). This can be written as bullet points instead of paragraph form, but your response needs to be formal and typed.
    1) State two facts presented by each side.
    2) State two opinions presented by each side.
    3) How credible is each author (empirical in presenting the thesis, good credentials, biased in any way)?
    4) Are there any logical errors (like faulty cause/effect relationships, distortion of information, faulty analogy, oversimplification, stereotyping, faulty generalization)? If so, explain where and how.
  • Sep 10 - Thur
  • Meet in the classroom (108 Walker) by 8:50am at the very latest for convocation. I will be in at about 8 or 8:15am with some birthday snacks. I was just sent an email that "The Holmes Center policy is that no bags or backpacks are permitted in the Holmes Center" so if you need to store something in my office, you can.
  • Sep 9 - Wed
  • If you didn't bring your $20, bring that in.
  • Research the web to find out what your name means. In addition, if you use a nickname, why did you choose to use it? If you use your given name, contact a parent or guardian to find out why they named you that - were you named after someone, for example?
  • Reflection on the summer reading book Three Cups of Tea. Message the following to me on ASULearn or turn in your answers at the beginning of class (also be prepared to discuss these, so you may want to make a copy of whatever you turn in). This can be written as bullet points instead of paragraph form, but your response needs to be formal and typed.
    1) What are the breakthroughs in the book?
    2) What are the controversies in the book?
    3) What are the instances when mathematics or science are mentioned? Summarize the instances and refer to specific page numbers.
  • 2 Sep - Wed
  • If you didn't already bring your $20, bring that in.
  • Research the web for a few quotes about breakthroughs or controversies in science or mathematics. Write down your quotes, the people, the years, and where you obtained them.
  • Obtain the two course books TAKING SIDES for purchase and Defining Moments for rental.
  • Take the survey on ASULearn about the TAKING SIDES topics you are most interested in.
  • If you have a laptop with Microsoft Office (Word, Powerpoint, Excel) on it, bring it to class.
  • Aug 31 - Mon
  • Read through the online syllabus - search google for Dr. Sarah, click on my page, and click on the First Year Seminar link and then the Syllabus link. Prepare to share something you read there and write down any questions you have - the university considers this a binding contract between us.
  • Read the SYNC reading online at ASULearn. Message me on ASULearn or turn in your answers at the beginning of class (also be prepared to discuss these, so you may want to make a copy of whatever you turn in). This can be written as bullet points instead of paragraph form, but your response needs to be formal and typed.
    1) What were the breakthroughs in this reading?
    2) What were the controversies in this reading?
    3) Write down the aspects that surprised you, that you found interesting, that you disagreed with, or that you had a question on.
    4) Write down one item that relates to something in your own life.
  • Bring $20.00 to Dr. Sarah to cover the cost of tickets for class outdoors programs and performing arts or other events.
  • Quote of the Day and Hannah's Tips

  • Hannah's Tip: Make sure you get proper sleep. The semester will get more difficult as the semester goes on, and sleep is vital to staying mentally healthy.
  • Dr. Sarah's Quote: This universality of applications [of mathematics] can be traced back to the fact that all aspects of Nature and areas of life are governed by the same principles of order and intelligence that have been discovered subjectively by mathematicians by referring back to the principles of intelligence in their own consciousness. [Maharishi Mahesh Yogi (1996). Maharishi's Absolute Theory of Defense. India: Age of Enlightenment Press. pp. 304-305]
  • Erin's Quote: It's not a matter of not understanding and it's not a matter of being adverse to what the thrust of the program is. It's a matter of identifying that there is a clear deficiency in these programs in terms of the development of basic skills. It seems silly that... parents and others have to ask and demand and force the schools to teach children basic skills. [Elizabeth Caron (An outraged parent) (2009). New, New Math = Controversy: Some Parents Launch Crusade Against New Approach. CBS Evening News with Katie Couric. Website: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2000/05/28/eveningnews/main200272.shtml]
  • Sam's Quote: Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited to all we now know and understand, while imagination embraces the entire world, and all there ever will be to know and understand. [Albert Einstein (1929). What Life Means to Einstein : An Interview by George Sylvester Viereck. The Saturday Evening Post. Vol. 202 (26 October 1929), p. 117.
  • Hannah's Tip: Skipping classes only hurts yourself in the long run. In a few semesters, there are going to be many more factors keeping you from making it to class (i.e. riding the bus, living off campus, work schedules, rigorous course study and homework, etc.). Find a way to get yourself motivated now!
  • Amber's Quote: Stem cells are like toenail clippings with a better career plan. [Schott Adams, unattributed]
  • Hannah's Tip: Success is often the result of taking a misstep in the right direction. [Al Bernstein, unattributed]
  • Hannah's Tip Have fun -football games, homecoming, fall break Oct 15-16.
  • Charlie's Quote Science is facts; just as houses are made of stone, so is science made of facts; but a pile of stones is not a house, and a collection of facts is not necessarily science. [Jules Henri Poincare (1902). La Science et l'hypothese. Flammarion.]
  • Hannah's Tip Don't feel pressured to make a desision about a major or career.
  • Graeme's quote Science without religion is lame, religion without science is blind. [Einstein (1941). Science, Philosophy and Religion: a Symposium. ]
  • Hannah's Tip Start thinking about potential classes for next semister because registration time will be here before you know it. It's always good to go into a meeting with your advisor with some ideas about that classes you want to take.
  • Allie's Quote I think what you are going to see is that DNA is for this century, what fingerprints were for last century. [Sarah Hart. Attributed in DNA Testing: The Controversy of Using It. Deborah Block. Washington, DC. 14 January 2005.]
  • Eitan's Quote The greatest discoveries of science have always been those that forced us to rethink our beliefs about the universe and our place in it. [Robert L. Park, in The New York Times, 7 December 1999.]
  • Amy's Quote If my student comes to me an says he wants to be useful to mankind and go into research to alleviate human suffering, I advise him to go into charity instead. Research wants real egotists who seek their own pleasure and satisfaction, but find it in solving the puzzles of nature. [Albert Szent-Gyorgi, Science Today, May 1980, p. 35]
  • Nick's Quote We can't solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them. [Albert Einstein, unattributed]
  • Ninja's Quote When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong. [Arthur C. Clarke, Profiles of the Future, 1962]
  • Hannah's Tip Look at the final exam schedule and make sure that you do not have 3 exams on one day - if you do, ask your professors whether any of the exams can be moved.
  • Reid's Quote Give me a place to stand and with a lever I will move the whole world. [Archimedes, ~220 BC, as referenced in John Tzetzes (12th century AD) Book of Histories (Chiliades) 2, 129-130 or Give me a place to stand and I will move the earth from On the lever in Pappus Synagoge]
  • Ashley's Quote The problem [with genetic research] is we're just starting down this path, feeling our way in the dark. We have a small lantern in the form of a gene, but the lantern doesn't penetrate more than a couple of hundred feet. We don't know whether we're going to encounter chasms, rock walls or mountain ranges along the way. We don't even know how long the path is. [Francis S Collins, Quoted in J. Madeleine Nash, et al., 'Tracking Down Killer Genes', Time magazine (17 Sep 1990).]
  • Blaire's Quote I'm sorry to say that the subject I most disliked was mathematics. I have thought about it. I think the reason was that mathematics leaves no room for argument. If you made a mistake, that was all there was to it. [Malcolm X, The Autobiography of Malcolm X (1965, 1999), 34.]
  • Chance's Quote The universe is full of magical things, patiently waiting for our wits to grow sharper. [Eden Phillpotts, A Shadow Passes, 1934, The Macmillan Co, p. 17]
  • Mackenzie's Quote Research is what I'm doing when I don't know what I'm doing. [Wernher Von Braun, unattributed]
  • Ryan's Quote A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new. [Albert Einstein, unattributed]
  • Kenzie's Quote Any fool can make things bigger, more complex, and more violent. It takes a touch of genius - and a lot of courage - to move in the opposite direction. [Albert Einstein, unattributed]